After a legal battle in France, Thuan and the Bogdanovs settled out of court, and the Bogdanovs later denied all wrongdoing. But in passing judgement the court stated that the scientist had "lacked prudence", given "the fame of the plaintiff".
Overbye wrote that Jackiw was intrigued by the thesis, although it contained many points he did not understand. First of all, I will say that I have deep respect for Alain Riazuelo, I had a look to his thesis and papers. Rather than suing Riazuelo for Bogdanov thesis reportsBogdanov filed a criminal complaint of copyright droit d'auteur violation against him in May Bogdanov subsequently described this version as "dating from and too unfinished to be made public".
Jackiw didn't understand, but he found it intriguing. On the other hand, George Johnson's report in The New York Times concludes that physicists have generally decided the papers are "probably just the result of fuzzy thinking, bad writing and journal referees more comfortable with correcting typos than challenging thoughts.
As he told the New York Times, Igor's thesis contained many points Jackiw did not understand; nonetheless, he found the work intriguing. The sentence was lenient: You can easily get ahold of these, because they are appended to the PDF files containing their theses.
The referee's report concluded: It showed some originality and some familiarity with the jargon. You will notice a few things: And I don't think it will get better I'm a little surprised that anyone is surprised at this. The controversy began in when Max Niedermaier, a physicist at the University of Toursemailed Ted Newman, a physicist at the University of Pittsburghalleging that the twins—who had previously had celebrity status for a science fiction television program in France—had spoofed their PhD theses.
Sometimes two referees make mistakes at the same time. The ensuing dispute received considerable coverage in the mainstream media.
The scientific language was just an appearance behind which hid incompetence and ignorance of even basic physics. In Augustthey presented a minute special cosmology program in which they introduced their theory among other cosmological scenarios.
He posted an unpublished version of Grichka Bogdanov's PhD thesis on his personal website, along with his critical analysis.
All these were ideas that could possibly make sense. Schreiber concluded, Just to make sure: During months, the Bogdanovs pretended to have academic support through the Hong Kong University Where did they pretend to have academic support?
They have the right to have their work recognized with a diploma, which is nothing much these days. We discuss then the conjecture according to which it might exist a general link between deformation cocycle ccurvature generally of the space of the phases of the system but here curvature of pre-spacetime Bogdanov thesis reports anomalies of the theory.
There's nothing much new in this one. Therefore here is a small contribution to the discussion. A number of English Wikipedia users, including Igor Bogdanov himself, were explicitly named in this ban.
This had to be corrected in the araticle and I did it. It contains quotes from various physicists criticizing the Bogdanoff's work, but also quotes defending it - especially from Daniel Sternheimer and Roman Jackiw. The Bogdanov affair has first been discussed extensively in the Usenet newsgroup sci.
Bogdanov thesis reports is surely an indictment of something, but its relevance to string theory is marginal at best. Antoniadis told Le Monde, I had given a favorable opinion for Grichka's defense, based on a rapid and indulgent reading of the thesis text. However, there are at this time no plans to withdraw the article.
He came to trial and was convicted in March I first learned of the relevant papers in a posting on the internet by Dr. This has been the basis of concerns raised about the efficacy of the peer-review system that the scientific community and academia use to determine the merit of submitted manuscripts for publication; one concern is that over-worked and unpaid referees may not be able to thoroughly judge the value of a paper in the little time they can afford to spend on it.
We discuss then the conjecture according to which it might exist a general link between deformation cocycle ccurvature generally of the space of the phases of the system but here curvature of pre-spacetime and anomalies of the theory. To all, try to take YBM 's version and include some of Igor's statements -- that he claims that this "Yang" person is a real one, and try to give a concise impression of his excuses for creating private organisations which sound incredibly like academic institutions and have a "University-of-Hong-Kong"-sounding domain name.
Messager The cosmologist is Alain Riazuelo; he wrote a lot of comments about the Bogdanoff's stuff, most of which can be seen on a French mathematics forum hosted by the University of Strasbourg.
Both the book and the Bogdanovs' television shows have been criticized for elementary scientific inaccuracies.According to Niedermaier, both Bogdanoffs conducted their thesis defense on the same day, in a rented hall with TV crews present.
In fact, it seems clear that the Bogdanoffs got their Ph.D.'s at different times. In Octoberthe CNRS report on the Bogdanov brothers' theses — the one that had been "quietly filed away" — came to light.
The report spends much longer — 15 pages — dissecting Igor Bogdanov’s physics thesis. It concludes: “Unfortunately, even a rapid reading evokes strong suspicions about the scientific contribution and about the quality of presentation of this work; and a deeper analysis only confirms these suspicions.
The Bogdanov Affair is an academic dispute regarding the legitimacy of a series of theoretical physics papers written by French twins Igor and Grichka Bogdanov (alternately spelt Bogdanoff).These papers were published in reputable scientific journals, and were alleged by their authors to culminate in a proposed theory for describing what occurred at the Big Bang.
The Bogdanov affair is an academic dispute regarding the legitimacy of a series of theoretical physics papers written by French twins Igor and Grichka Bogdanov (alternately spelt Bogdanoff).These papers were published in reputable scientific journals, and were alleged by their authors to culminate in a proposed theory for describing what occurred at the Big Bang.
REPORT ON THE THESIS OF teachereducationexchange.comOV Report by Shahn Majid, January 26, Dear Professor Sternheimer, I have had a chance to look at the final version of the thesis, particularly Chapter 3 relating.
On 29 th of OctoberBourgogne University issued a text about Igor & Grichka Bogdanoff thesis in mathematics and theoretical physics.Download